The spent fuel from nuclear power plants is actually a precious resource. The nuclear power plant of the future may be floating near russia offshore reactors could be cheaper, safer and more flexible, proponents say, making them a useful weapon against climate change. Rhetorical analysis nuclear waste anthony white eng. They sang together to pass the time during their 12hour shifts, notes one doe article. This book aims to cover the practice and research efforts that are currently conducted to deal with the technical difficulties in different radioactive waste. The wipp facility is temporarily closed, following an accident in 2014, and is scheduled to reopen later this year. Nuclear waste richard a muller essay click here essay about the turn of the screw the fact writing an essay gcse english the sun bore down on my head hotter friend an unhappy creative writing essay tips helped can i write an.
Anthony white eng 2 83018 professor wu 22 february 2014 rhetorical analysis nuclear waste in nuclear waste richard muller takes on the issue of storing nuclear biproducts inside the yucca mountain in nevada. I, not being interested in nuclear waste, was not interested in this reading. Based on the authors recent investigations, this book describes the application of glassy and polyphase composite materials for nuclear waste immobilisation. This nasty term was invented just to stop the development of civilian nuclear power. Weve now reduced the freakishly radioactive waste we cannot use to a much smaller mass and recycled the fuel.
My daughter elizabeth and i have found the obvious way to dispose off nuclear waste. Worldwide, 240,000 tonnes of spent fuel from nuclear reactors is in storage, mostly in surface facilities, according to alexander bychkov of the international. Everyone has their own perspective of the issue of nuclear waste, and what to do about it. At first glance, mullers nuclear waste they say i say. Worries about the dangers that nuclear plants and their radioactive waste posed to nearby communities grew over time, and plant construction in the united states virtually died after the early 1980s. In society, many debates are held over trying to prove to the world that this substance is harmful. In a recent video interview with the wall street journal, muller said that despite the fact that the accident at fukushima was far less. While the question may be simple, the answer is quite complex. Summary of nuclear waste nuclear waste is dangerous, isnt it. They both received macarthur foundation fellowships aka genius grants several decades ago muller in 1982 and lovins in 1993. Muller did an excellent job of saying why nuclear waste matters to conscious american citizens. Rhetorical analysis nuclear waste anthony white eng 2. Global warming is real, but the things they attribute to climate change. Well, the koch foundation provided about one quarter or maybe it was onesixth of our funding and they made it clear to us that the reason they funded us was that we did recognize that these issues were real, issues that michael mann did not accept as real.
The safe management of nuclear and radioactive wastes is a subject that has recently received considerable recognition due to the huge volume of accumulative wastes and the increased public awareness of the hazards of these wastes. They say i say identifies the key rhetorical moves in academic writing, showing students how to frame their arguments in the larger context of what others have said and providing templates to help them make those moves. We have waste and we have to do something about with it muller 210. Karen gaffney, raritan valley community college a brilliant book. Nuclear waste or radioactive waste is the residue of nuclear reactors, nuclear researches, nuclear projects and nuclear bomb reaction.
Everything that rises must converge flannery oconnor. However, is it really dangerous or is it just harmful to an extent. The science behind the headlines about a rational, sciencebased approach to nuclear energy as an important and valuable energy source. The issue of nuclear waste is not one that people take lightly and is a very. Without a doubt, the topic of energyfrom coal, oil, and nuclear to geothermal, solar and windis one of the most pressing across the globe. Richard muller is a professor of physics at the university of california at berkely. Uranium is mined, milled, converted into uranium hexafluoride, and then enriched. What are prof richard mullers ideas on storage of nuclear. Nuclear waste and nuclear ethics nuclear files from.
The technology is so compelling that were able to bring onboard these worldclass experts who say. What are prof richard mullers ideas on storage of nuclear waste. There are two points that resulted in me downgrading the persuasiveness of the book and they relate. Australias stable geography is suitable for belowground nuclear storage. Muller nuclear waste is a radioactive waste that is dangerous, and a fair percentage of people would agree on this topic.
Sep 20, 2012 the other issue that people bring up is nuclear waste storage, and they say nuclear waste lasts for thousands of years. Muller actually does a poor, ineffective job of communicating his ideas by using an poor pathos, a pathetic logos, and a piteous ethos. Nuclear waste site consultation was rigged to favour. Jul 14, 2016 nuclear waste authorities in canada and britain are looking at possible sites. Oct 19, 2010 we have waste and we have to do something about with it muller 210. Purchase an introduction to nuclear waste immobilisation 2nd edition. Nuclear waste is the leftover nucleus of elements that were split and the result of nuclear fuel. Nuclear waste news, research and analysis the conversation. Tourism argumentative example essay problemfocused assessment is an ongoing process integrated with nursing care to determine the status of a specific.
Nuclear wastes, also known as spent fuel, are dangerously radioactive and could exist for thousands of years. It is of paramount importance to policy makers, economists, environmentalists, and industry as they consider which technologies to invest in, how to promote use of renewable energy sources, and how to. Energy ebook by jose goldemberg 9780199942732 rakuten kobo. Muller first brings to light the most common fears of storing nuclear waste. They say i say the moves that matter in academic writing. But before reactors can be built the government needs to specify how the waste can be stored. Will we actually get a place to store our nuclear waste. Originally perceived as a cheap and plentiful source of power, the commercial use of nuclear energy has been controversial for decades. Nuclear waste is a big controversy in todays society as we face the challenges of handling, caring, and storing these products after we have produced the highly touted nuclear power. In society, many debates are held over trying to nbsp. The public conversion of ucberkeley professor richard muller into a preacher of unscientific agw dogma as truth bears little or no resemblance to the conversion of the saul into paul on the road to damascus this appears to be pr public relations carefully wrapped in a sheepskin of hd human drama that will not help the reputation of agw. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading nuclear 2.
Nuclear waste authorities in canada and britain are looking at possible sites. Drawing on the authors extensive experience in the processing and disposal of waste, an introduction to nuclear waste immobilisation, second edition examines the gamut of nuclear waste issues from the natural level of radionuclides in the environment to geological disposal of wasteforms and their longterm behavior. Although he seems to do an adequate job of informing about nuclear waste removable solutions, in his essay, nuclear waste, richard a. Muller suggests a few solutions for the growing problem of nuclear waste but fails to connect them or prove that one is superior. About 96% of it can be recycled into new nuclear fuel.
The new atoms, ruining our chain reaction, are only a teeny percentage of the spent rods. In the essay nuclear waste, author richard muller expresses his concern about how to dispose of nuclear waste. The whole purpose of this writing was to deliver information based off of his studies and his confessions on nuclear waste. Jun 25, 2014 nuclear waste richard a muller essay click here essay about the turn of the screw the fact writing an essay gcse english the sun bore down on my head hotter friend an unhappy creative writing essay tips helped can i write an. Nuclear waste richard a muller essay 828076 grants and. Nuclear waste may get a second life if nuclear waste was handled by a technology called reprocessing, more energy could be extracted from it, keeping more radioactive material out. They both get a lot of attention from the commercial media and from elected politicians. He also fails to prove why other ideas are better or worse than others, he simply slithers in and around other ideas just pointing out a flaw while the idea he supports has just as many flaws if not more.
His coauthor, elizabeth muller, is his daughter and. Jan 18, 2014 supporters of nuclear energy say it is a lowcarbon way to secure the uks power supply. This is one book im not selling back to the bookstore. Aug 15, 2011 the first comprehensive history and overview of u. On march 20 they announced a startup called deep isolation that aims to store nuclear waste. United voices against storing nuclear waste in northern saskatchewan. There is a gigawatt in a square kilometer of sunlight, and thats about the same as a nuclear power plant. Say no to nuclear in northern saskatchewan home facebook. A fascinating new interview with prof richard muller, quote. Muller, a professor of physics at the university of california at berkeley, gives his thoughts on the matter of nuclear waste in his essay entitled nuclear waste.
All i would need would be a few hundred kilograms of either highly enriched uranium or purified plutonium239. The youths needed 30 minutes each day to wash the graphite dust off their skin. Richard mullers article on how important the subject of nuclear waste is. Oct 27, 2019 nuclear waste is dangerous, will outlast our civilisation and needs to be dealt with as safely as possible. Muller speaks on scientific research about nuclear waste storage, other peoples theories, and alternative ways of storing this type of waste. Use the templates in they say i say for representing the words of others and for introducing quotations.
Muller found in the back of the book in the first paragraph, muller mentions loaded terms such as. No other fuel source can make this claimwood, coal, oil, or gas. Sources of nuclear waste are described including the nuclear fuel cycle, operational and spent nuclear fuel reprocessing. This underground facility in a large body of rock is known as a repository. The new york times bestselling book on academic writingin use at more than 1,500 schools. Nuclear energy generates 75% of frances electricity, and ongoing troubles at the new flamanville epr reactor have raised crucial questions about its future in the countrys electricity mix. In this essay he uses scientific fact to support his opinions, mixing personal views with science. Muller the article, nuclear waste, by richard muller discusses the dangers of nuclear waste and his criticism of how important figures are handling the situation. Richard muller has a lot in common with amory lovins. His etiquette throughout this journal was very studious. Nobody ever mentions the fact that waste from coal lasts hundreds of millions of years, and in many ways is more dangerous than the waste from a nuclear reactor. It covers allimportant aspects of processing and immobilization, including. Muller, an awardee of the macarthur fellowship and physics professor at uc berkley, states in his 2008 essay nuclear waste, that americans and the rest of the world are overly concerned with radioactive debris and the possibility of nuclear contamination. The futile pursuit of the american dream barbara ehrenreich.
Your goal for this assignment is to summarize the articles main ideas and important points clearly, concisely, and accurately. Mar 06, 2018 critics always say any ideas about handling nuclear waste are bad but leaving them where they are is not acceptable, then never suggest any scientificallycredible solutions. Nuclear waste could be stored in vaults deep underneath national parks after mps approved a new plan for the uks most toxic radioactive materials. Is access to nuclear energy worth the risk of creating nuclear waste.
As president you will need to make decisions that require thinking like a physicist. That is not easy to obtain, and i suspect the material that north korea would be willing to sell me would only be good enou. Critics always say any ideas about handling nuclear waste are bad but leaving them where they are is not acceptable, then never suggest any scientificallycredible solutions. Very little of the book can really be said to relate to the title. An introduction to nuclear waste immobilisation 2nd edition. The irresistable story of richard muller climate etc. He advocates that nuclear waste causes many problems and costs billions of dollars to store. A marvelously readable and levelheaded explanation of basic science and how it relates to. You know, i cant tell where the foundation is going to put its money thats beyond me but i think when you say ive now reached agreement with 98%, i actually disagree with most of that 98% on many of the things they say, if not most things. Aug 04, 2012 by judith curry the story surrounding richard muller is providing some interesting insights into the psychodynamics of climate change science. A fascinating new interview with prof richard muller. We could chemically break down the fuel, purify for uranium and create new fuel from the old. Elizabeth muller have come up with one of the more unusual fatherdaughter businesses in recent memory.
Why a green future needs nuclear power kindle edition by lynas, mark. Richard and jane stewart expertly analyze the changing policies. The book sheds light on the role of population growth in energy consumption, renewable energy resources, the amount of available energy reserves and when they will run out, geopolitical issues, environmental problems, the frequency of environmental disasters, energy efficiency, new technologies, and solutions to changing consumption patterns. Richard muller, physicist from the university of california, berkeley recently released energy for future presidents. As the paper unveils, all people engaging in the nuclear waste debate are. New developments in glassy nuclear wasteforms michael i. The best tribute to they say i say ive heard is this, from a student. Supporters of nuclear energy say it is a lowcarbon way to secure the uks power supply. Energy ebook by jose goldemberg 9780199942732 rakuten. What is remarkable is that others havent thought of this, but we think that is the result of us government policy that doesnt allow private companies or individ. There is no way we can claim that we will be able to store nuclear waste for. It introduces immobilisation issues beginning with a short description of nuclear waste types and compositions.
351 1421 1495 1196 578 1461 355 767 1207 570 1594 1196 1555 1583 24 1118 858 995 417 1550 1420 1470 60 282 402 120 744 597 634 1069 968 155 225 412